L'Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review - Before & After - Really Ree
By Ree

L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review – Before & After

14 Apr 2015 (Updated: 7 Mar 2016)

*Links marked with asterisks are affiliate links, these help Ree with running costs of the blog

main product image

Oh I do love trying new mascaras, particularly because my lashes are literally nowhere without a couple of coats of something good. So I was very (very) excited to try the brand new L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara. The name sold it to me before I even managed to get hold of it!

l'oreal-paris-superstar-mascara-review-before-after
L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review

So what do we have here? So for me this looks like a bit of a return to the old school 2 step mascaras where one end is white and the other is black. They used to get me seriously charged up back in the day! I have always loved an extra step, but I do remember some issues with flecks of white poking through. Not so with this one I am pleased to say.

l'oreal-paris-superstar-mascara-review
L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review

So what we are promised here is “staggering volume, thanks to 2 synergic steps”.  I don’t remember anything about synergic steps back in the day, just one white one and then one black one. Things have moved on!?

L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara – 2 Steps

Step 1 – Volume

l'oreal-paris-superstar-mascara-review-step-1
L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review

This is what is being described as a ‘super sizing white volumising primer’ that thickens lashes one by one for superstar volume! It uses a shaping mascara brush that promises to comb each lash, even the hard to reach ones.

Step 2 – Lengthen

l'oreal-paris-superstar-mascara-review-step-2
L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review

Here’s where a black fibre-rich top coat formula does its magic. It is applied with a lifting brush that coats the white primer for an intense black finish.

Totally up for this! So of course I tested it out!

L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Before & After Photos

Before:

l'oreal-paris-superstar-mascara-review-before
L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review – Before Photo

After Step 1:

l'oreal-paris-superstar-mascara-swatch-step-1
L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review – Step 1

After Step 1 & 2:

l'oreal-paris-superstar-mascara-swatch-step-2
L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review – Step 1 & 2
l'oreal-paris-superstar-mascara-review-after
L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review – After Photo

You’ll notice that I have some very naughty lashes on the left that just stick straight up no matter what I do. They’ve been doing that for about 2 weeks. No idea…

Well what do you think? I am impressed, I’ll tell you that! I thought that the chat about synergy between the 2 steps was just jargon but they do actually feel like they work well together. In the old days I could never get the black to cover the white, and sometimes I got grey (!) but step 2 seems to stick straight on to the white primer very effectively.

They are certainly very volumised and lengthened, and at first I could actually see my lashes as I blinked, a lot like when I wear false lashes, so that must stand for something! Also, despite the volumised appearance, my lashes still feel flexible and light – not at all crispy. Thumbs up.

L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara is out now. Find it HERE for £10.99

Ree

XXX

Unless otherwise indicated products reviewed are press or brand examples. Links may be affiliated links which means that if you make a purchase though one of our links we receive a small commission which helps support and run this website.

Share this story

View comments

9 thoughts on “L’Oreal Paris Superstar Mascara Review – Before & After

  1. Hello! I love your blog! I watch it every day! I had one question about that mascara: how do you remove it? Is it like the red and white lash extension mascara from L’Oréal , with warm water?

    Thank you!

  2. I’m always afraid the fibers will get in my eyes and irritate/scratch them. Also, I’m not wearing contacts but if I do in the future it seems like they could get under them and irritate…per Tati Westbrook (Glamlife Guru) on YouTube. Opinion?

  3. i’m really intrigued by this .

    is the formula really wet or is it more on the dry side ?

    i have stubbornly straight lashes , so wet formulas weigh them down no matter how much I curl them .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

back to top